Summary + Thesis + Support Draft #2

-

 Thesis Statement (My assertion):

The Apple Vision Pro showcases the vast potential of mixed reality across work, entertainment and training. However, while it has applications in the engineering industry, its design and hardware limitations make it less suitable compared to AR headsets specifically developed for engineering workflows.

Primary Support #1: 

The Apple Vision Pro's size and weight makes it unsuitable for fieldwork. This makes it uncomfortable for extended field use in construction environments where comfort is crucial.

Primary Support #2: 

The Apple Vision Pro relies on intuitive hand gesture controls which can be dangerous in hazardous field environments like construction sites.

Primary Support #3:

Due to its consumer-centric design, the Apple Vision Pro has hardware limitations for civil engineering. It lacks support for engineering software like AutoCAD and Revit, preventing it from overlaying 3D designs to scale on physical construction sites. 

Counterargument: 

While the Apple Vision Pro is not ideal for fieldwork and training in Civil Engineering, it can be fully optimized for office work. Civil Engineers who travel to construction cites can use the headset for zoom meetings, reviewing AutoCAD drawings, and making design revisions remotely, improving collaboration and productivity.

Conclusion:

Although the Apple Vision Pro may not be ideal for fieldwork on construction sites or training, it can still optimize workflow, enhance productivity, and improve project collaboration. As spatial computing advances, Apple may one day develop a future version of the Apple Vision Pro that is tailored for engineering, offering enhanced collaboration and fieldwork capabilities. 


References:

Apple Inc. (2023, June 5). Introducing Apple Vision Pro: Apple’s first spatial computer. Apple Newsroom. Retrieved from https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2023/06/introducing-apple-vision-pro/ 

Fill, H.-G. (2024). Spatial conceptual modeling: Anchoring knowledge in the real world. arXiv preprint arXiv:2407.17259. Retrieved from https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.17259 

Xu, J., Doyle, D., & Moreu, F. (2021). State of the art of augmented reality (AR) capabilities for civil infrastructure applications. arXiv preprint arXiv:2110.08698. Retrieved from https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.08698 

Comments

  1. Brad BlackstoneFebruary 9, 2025 at 9:49 PM

    Thanks for sharing.

    You have clear controlling ideas in the thesis -- ...its design and hardware limitations make it less suitable compared to AR headsets.... -- but the primary supports are very specific in the terms used. I wonder if you could enhance the thesis by explicitly mentioning in it the points mentioned in the primary support sentences.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A formal self-introduction

-
Image
 Subject: Formal letter of introduction Dear Professor Blackstone, My name is Zenden Soh, a student in your class for this trimester. I am writing to introduce myself and to share more about my background and goals for this module.    Prior to enrolling in the Civil Engineering degree programme at the Singapore Institute of Technology (SIT), I previously studied Electrical Engineering at ITE College East and Electrical and Electronic Engineering at Singapore Polytechnic (SP). I was never particularly interested in the field of engineering from the beginning, in fact I even considered theological studies at different points. However, I like analysing things and so I chose the path of engineering. Despite my background in Electrical engineering, it was only in university did I decide to pursue Civil Engineering instead.    One of my hobbies is photography, particularly street photography and landscape photography. I often go on spontaneous photowalks in Singapore...
Read more

Assignment 3: Critical Reflection

-
 Module Learning: Prior to the start of this module, my goals for this class was to improve my communication skills, particularly in report writing. My time in National Service, though fruitful had given me the opportunity to interact with individuals from all walks of life. This transformed the way that I communicated with others, but it also dwindled my ability to communicate professionally. Looking back over the past 13 weeks, I believed that I have gained more than I expected. The materials covered in class was extensive, and though I often struggled with them, realizing how essential these skills are in the future helped me to stay focused in my learning. The concepts taught in class such as the Paul-Elder Framework and Dewey's model of Reflection have been instrumental in helping me to conceptualize my ideas and put them into paper. In doing so, I was able to refine my thought process from ideation to planning and creation. One thing that I truly appreciated was how we were e...
Read more

Individual Research Contributions to Group Project (Atom XYZ Headset)

-
Updated on 28/02/2025: Wrote the team minutes on Google Docs.  Researched on the Atom XYZ headset via ChatGPT and Google. Tried to find if there was any consumer reviews online so that we can identify a potential problem but to no avail. I then realised that one problem that users might experience is motion sickness due to the change in the depth of field from the VR headsets. I then used ChatGPT to find academic literature to support my hypothesis.  Once it was verified, I proposed it to the group a potential problem statement. I then wrote the ideal and goal, problem statement and report title and finalized it with the team. Created our approach to writing the Technical Report with the team. Created a google doc so that everyone can collaborate on it. Updated on 07/03/2025: Found out that the company which made the MotionCure, our solution, had went out of business. After discussing with the team and presenting an alternative, we found a resolution and proceeded with the rep...
Read more